Minor penalty cannot automatically disqualify govt staff from promotion: HC | Jaipur News

img gavel 2 2 1 lslkv4jpjpg https://jaipur.visitinrajasthan.com/wp-content/uploads/2023/10/cropped-cropped-R-2.png

Minor penalty cannot automatically disqualify govt staff from promotion: HC

Jaipur: Rajasthan High Court has ruled that a govt employee cannot be denied consideration for promotion solely because of a minor penalty imposed during the preceding seven years. However, Departmental Promotion Committee (DPC) can consider such penalties while assessing the employee’s overall service record and suitability.A full bench comprising Chief Justice Sanjay K Agrawal and Justices Sameer Jain and Pramil Kumar Mathur delivered the ruling on Nov 18, clarifying the scope of the seven-year penalty rule. It held that censure or withholding of one grade increment without cumulative effect cannot automatically render an otherwise eligible employee unsuitable for promotion.“The mere existence of such a penalty within seven years cannot lead to an automatic finding of unsuitability or become a ground to deny promotion simply because a govt circular provides for it,” the bench observed.The dispute concerned Department of Personnel circulars issued on July 26, 2006 and June 4, 2008, and subsequent instructions dated Oct 22, 2024. The court held that executive instructions cannot create a disqualification not prescribed under the governing statutory service rules.Rule 14 of Rajasthan Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1958, lists censure and withholding of increments as penalties but does not prescribe any period of ineligibility for promotion following such punishment.The bench clarified that while minor penalties cannot exclude an employee from the zone of consideration, the DPC can assess their impact on suitability. In promotions based on seniority-cum-merit, penalties imposed within seven years may form part of this assessment.The reference arose from the case of police officer Ajay Kant Ratudi, appointed sub-inspector in 1996 and promoted to inspector in 2013. He received three censure penalties in Dec 2017, June 2019 and June 2021. The dispute concerned his consideration for promotion to Rajasthan Police Service (Junior Scale).The full bench directed that his pending writ petition be placed before the appropriate bench for a decision considering its ruling.

Source link

Rate this post

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *